Aletheia wrote: ↑Sat May 04, 2019 3:00 am
I picked the claim you made about garlic as the concrete example, because it seems to me to be something that is clear-cut enough to be amenable to experiment.
Anyway, thank you for your clarification. So, re-writing the above taking the clarification into account, it would be:
Just as your mother is the real authority when it comes to issue of saying who your father is, because she had first hand experience no other woman has of that issue
Lord Krishna is the real authority when it comes to the issue of saying whether garlic is good to eat, because he has first hand experience no other being has of that issue
Similarly, Lord Krishna's first disciple has first hand experience of what Lord Krishna said.
Lord Krishna's second disciple has first hand experience of what Lord Krishna's first disciple said.
And so on, in an unbroken chain, ending with Srila Prabhupada who has first hand experience of what the disciple previous to him said.
Which raising three questions:
(A) Was there really an unbroken chain?
(B) Is it possible that, at some point along the chain, someone lied?
(C) Even if there were no deliberate liars in the chain, is it possible that, like in the game of "Chinese Whispers" information got distorted along the way?
as i said before that real thing is S*x life not the cheap garlics, and why people eat garlics ? just to increase S*x power. that is the real cause.
anyways no eating garlics is in do list, and no illicit S*x ( which means no S*x with another mans wife or no S*x outside marriage ) is also do list, for S*x life is allowed only with `1's wife not like cats and dogs and pigs mingle with anything and everyone.
_____________
and was there an unbroken chain ? yes Practical it is visible before you and Srila Prabhupada is current recognized agent of Lord Krishna.
and even among human beings chain is coming from Lord Krishna for he has gave creation first push and than all successful pushes are taking place.
for if you can trace out that who is your fathers, fathers, fathers, fathers, fathers, father than at the top you will find Krishna, instead of your false propanganda of evolution, big bang or this or that etc.
for material nature is not creative at its own, someone has to mix bottle of oxygen and bottle of hydrogen than they become water.
otherwise if you place them near each other and wait that they will combine at there own than that day will never come.
cuz material nature is not creative but it is spirit soul or the person who is creative and is working.
similarly entire creation is working under the directions of Lord Krishna.